Have a Large Tax Bill? Is Your Refund Not What You Expected? The New W-4 May Be Your Savior.

by Tracey Hrica, EA Jan 09, 2020 | Share

If only it weren’t so overwhelming.Last year, we were hit with many tax rule changes due to the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. Changes in the tax tables had a big impact on withholding, leading to tax bills and smaller refunds during last year’s tax filing season.

This year we are faced with a completely redesigned W-4 form for 2020.  Employees use the W-4 to adjust their payroll withholdings so that it’s close to their actual full-year income tax liability.

The first thing you need to know is that the new form is not required for existing employees. So, even though the new form is no longer based on the former withholding allowances that were tied to personal and dependency exemptions, employers and payroll processing providers need to maintain systems that can handle allowance-based calculations, as well as the new 2020 W-4 inputs.

But, for those hired beginning January 1st, 2020, as well as anyone who wants to adjust their withholding, the 2020 version is the only valid Form W-4.

So, what has changed?

  1. There are no more Single 1’s or Married 0’s. The new form is a dollar based calculation.
  2. The new W-4 features a checkbox for those with multiple jobs, as well as two-income households.
  3. It allows for Head of Household as a filing status.
  4. There are inputs for full-year child and dependent credits.
  5. There are inputs for full-year expected other income.
  6. There are inputs for full-year expected deductions(over the standard deduction amount).

Completing the new W-4 involves 5 steps.  Keep in mind that only Steps 1 and 5 are required (name, address, filing status, and signature).  Steps 2 and 3 should only be completed if they apply to the taxpayer, and Step 4 is optional.  Completing Step 4 may help ensure that withholding is accurate.

Let’s take a closer look at the 5-step process.

Step 1 – Input personal information, including filing status.
Step 2 – This step is for employees with multiple jobs or have spouses who also work. There are three options.
  1. Use the online withholding estimator for the most accurate withholding. Consider using the estimator if you:
    • Expect to work only part of the year
    • Have dividend or capital gains income, or are subject to additional taxes, such as the additional Medicare tax
    • Have self-employment income
  2.  Use the multiple jobs worksheet on page 3. This works the same as the online calculator, but with a little less accuracy.
  3.  Check the box. The IRS emphasizes that if an employee opts for the checkbox, BOTH spouses should check the box on each W-4 form.  However, only ONE spouse should complete steps 3 and 4(a) and (b), which are child and dependent tax credits, other income, and deductions. If the box is checked, the tax tables divide the standard deduction and tax brackets equally between two jobs. This option is roughly accurate for jobs with similar pay.
Step 3 – Remember, this step should only be filled out by ONE spouse.


Here you enter the number of dependents for whom a federal tax credit can be claimed.  To qualify for the child tax credit, the child must be under age 17 as of December 31st, must be your dependent who lives with you for more than half the year, and has a social security number. You can also include other tax credits in this step such as education credits.  Keep in mind that including these credits will increase your paycheck but reduce the amount of refund you will receive when you file your tax return.

Step 4 –  Enter other income and deductions.
  1. (a) Enter full-year non-wage income such as rental income, interest, and dividends. However, line 4(a) does not address self-employment tax.  Taxpayers with a mix of W-2s and 1099s should use the IRS online calculator.
  2. (b) Here you can enter the estimated full-year dollar amount of deductions OVER the standard deduction amount. For example, a Married Filing Jointly family with expected total deductions of $40,000(mortgage interest, charitable donations, etc) in 2020 should enter $15,200 on line 4(b) – – [$40,00 minus the standard deduction of $24,800 in 2020] – – rather than total deductions.
  3. (c)Enter any additional tax you want withheld each pay period. This is another option by which employees can adjust for more complicated tax situations. Line 4(c) is the only entry that asks for a per-payroll All other entries are full-year amounts.

All in all, the new W-4 will help taxpayers have an accurate amount of tax withheld from their paychecks.

However, what are the drawbacks?

  1. Employees need more information to figure their withholding, such as their spouse’s pay statements, other sources of income, and their most recent tax return.
  2. Employees may need time and access to a computer to use the online calculator.
  3. Employers need to plan on more time for on-boarding.
  4. Any employee hired and first paid after 2019 who fails to complete the W-4 (an employee cannot be forced to do so) is treated as a single filer with no adjustments.

If you are a W-2 employee and find yourself with a large tax bill or conversely a large refund this year, you may want to enlist the help of your tax preparer or accountant to complete a new W-4.

Finally, for employers:  Remember to retain employee payroll records, including completed W-4s, for a minimum of 4 year after filing employer tax returns for the fourth quarter of the year.

About the Author

Tracey Hrica, EA

Tracey Hrica joined the firm in 1995. She is an Enrolled Agent(EA), which enables her to prepare personal and business tax returns and represent clients before the IRS. Working closely with her clients, Tracey’s primary areas of concentration are new client set up and QuickBooks support. As a QuickBooks ProAdvisor, she works closely with clients who rely on QuickBooks for the day to day running of their business. Tracey has expertise in both QuickBooks Desktop and QuickBooks Online.

See all blogs


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow us

Follow us to get the latest news from your preferred Social Network

Latest Articles

To the Relief of Small Business Owners, Congress Approves PPP Loan Changes

Well, it’s as good as official, the Senate appro...

Tax Preparation Checklist

We all know that tax day has been pushed to July 1...

Spread the Word to Protect Your Loved Ones from COVID-19 Related Scams

Scammers are taking advantage of the uncertainty, ...

PPP Forgiveness Application and Related Concerns

Hello everyone!  We took a little break from writ...

Is There Really Such a Thing as Free Money?

Will the PPP Loan be the “Free Money” Everyone...